TCP CPA Exam: Calculate Section 1245 and 1250 Depreciation Recapture

Share This...

Introduction

What is Depreciation Recapture?

In this article, we’ll calculate section 1245 and 1250 depreciation recapture. Depreciation recapture is a tax provision that applies when a taxpayer sells an asset that has been subject to depreciation deductions. Depreciation is a method used to allocate the cost of an asset over its useful life, allowing taxpayers to reduce their taxable income during the period the asset is in use. When the asset is eventually sold, any gain on the sale must account for the fact that the asset’s tax basis was reduced by depreciation deductions.

Depreciation recapture ensures that the gain attributed to these depreciation deductions is not taxed as a capital gain but rather as ordinary income. This is because the tax benefit was already received during the years when depreciation was claimed, and the IRS wants to recapture that benefit when the asset is sold.

Importance of Understanding Depreciation Recapture for Tax Purposes

Understanding depreciation recapture is crucial for tax professionals and CPA candidates because it affects the tax treatment of gains on depreciable property. Misclassifying the gain or failing to properly calculate the recapture can lead to incorrect tax filings, potential penalties, and an increased tax burden for individuals and businesses.

For example, without accounting for depreciation recapture, a taxpayer might mistakenly believe that all gains on the sale of an asset qualify for lower capital gains tax rates. However, if the gain is subject to recapture, part of it may be taxed at higher ordinary income tax rates, significantly affecting the overall tax liability.

Depreciation recapture is also a frequent topic on the CPA exam, especially in areas focusing on the taxation of property transactions. CPA candidates must be able to distinguish between different types of property and know when and how to apply recapture rules to accurately report taxable income.

Overview of Sections 1245 and 1250 of the Internal Revenue Code (IRC)

The Internal Revenue Code (IRC) contains two primary sections governing depreciation recapture: Section 1245 and Section 1250.

Section 1245 applies to depreciable personal property and certain types of intangible property, such as machinery, equipment, and patents. Under Section 1245, any gain realized on the sale of the asset up to the amount of depreciation claimed is taxed as ordinary income.
Section 1250 applies to depreciable real property, such as buildings and structural components. Unlike Section 1245, Section 1250 only recaptures “excess depreciation,” which is the amount of accelerated depreciation over the straight-line depreciation method. For gains above this, any unrecaptured gain is taxed as a capital gain, often at a special rate of up to 25%.

Both sections aim to recapture depreciation deductions that reduced taxable income during the asset’s useful life, but they apply differently based on the type of property involved. These distinctions are critical for tax professionals to understand, as they determine whether the gain on a sale will be taxed as ordinary income or at a lower capital gains rate.

Understanding Depreciation Recapture

Definition and Purpose of Depreciation Recapture

Depreciation recapture is a tax provision designed to “recapture” the tax benefits a taxpayer received by claiming depreciation deductions on an asset. When a taxpayer sells an asset that was previously depreciated, the IRS requires the taxpayer to pay ordinary income taxes on the portion of the sale gain that is attributable to those depreciation deductions. This prevents taxpayers from benefiting twice—once from the deduction and again from the lower capital gains tax rate when selling the asset.

The primary purpose of depreciation recapture is to ensure that any gain resulting from depreciation deductions is appropriately taxed as ordinary income. This reflects the idea that depreciation was initially used to reduce taxable income, and therefore, any recovery of that reduction should not be treated as a capital gain, which is often taxed at a lower rate.

Tax Implications of Depreciation Recapture

The tax implications of depreciation recapture are significant because it converts part of the gain on the sale of a depreciated asset from capital gain to ordinary income. Generally, capital gains are taxed at preferential rates (0%, 15%, or 20%, depending on the taxpayer’s income level). However, under depreciation recapture rules, the portion of the gain that is attributable to the depreciation deductions taken during the asset’s life is taxed at the taxpayer’s ordinary income tax rate, which can be as high as 37% for individuals.

This means that when a taxpayer sells a depreciable asset, any portion of the sale price that exceeds the asset’s adjusted basis, up to the total amount of depreciation previously claimed, will be taxed as ordinary income. Only the amount of the gain above the recaptured depreciation amount may qualify for the more favorable capital gains rates.

Key Differences Between Section 1245 and Section 1250 Recapture Rules

Section 1245 Recapture
Section 1245 of the IRC governs the recapture of depreciation on personal property and certain intangible assets. These assets include machinery, equipment, and certain intangibles like patents. The rule is straightforward: any gain on the sale of a Section 1245 property is recaptured as ordinary income up to the total amount of depreciation previously claimed. In other words, the entire depreciation deduction is recaptured if the asset is sold for more than its depreciated value.

Example: If an asset had an original purchase price of $50,000, with $30,000 of depreciation claimed over its useful life, and it is sold for $40,000, $30,000 of the gain would be recaptured as ordinary income under Section 1245.

Section 1250 Recapture
Section 1250 applies to real property (e.g., buildings and improvements) and involves a more complex recapture calculation. Unlike Section 1245, which recaptures all depreciation, Section 1250 only recaptures the excess depreciation—the amount of depreciation taken that exceeds what would have been allowed under the straight-line method. For real estate, most depreciation is now done using the straight-line method, so Section 1250 recapture often applies only to property where accelerated depreciation methods were used.

Unrecaptured Gain: Gains that are not recaptured as ordinary income under Section 1250 may still be taxed at a higher capital gains rate (up to 25%) on the “unrecaptured Section 1250 gain.”
Example: If a building had $100,000 of total depreciation, but only $20,000 was excess depreciation due to an accelerated method, only that $20,000 would be subject to recapture as ordinary income. The remaining $80,000 of gain may be taxed at capital gains rates, but possibly at the special 25% rate for unrecaptured Section 1250 gain.

Key Differences:

Types of Property: Section 1245 applies to personal property, while Section 1250 applies to real property.
Recaptured Amount: Section 1245 recaptures the entire depreciation, while Section 1250 only recaptures the excess depreciation (above straight-line).
Tax Treatment: Section 1245 recaptured gain is always taxed as ordinary income, while Section 1250 recaptured gain may be taxed at ordinary income rates only for excess depreciation, with the remaining gain potentially subject to a 25% rate or lower capital gains rates.

These distinctions are critical for determining how much of the gain on the sale of depreciated property is subject to ordinary income tax, and how much qualifies for capital gains treatment. Understanding these rules is essential for effective tax planning and compliance.

Section 1245 Depreciation Recapture

Assets Subject to Section 1245

Section 1245 of the Internal Revenue Code applies to certain types of depreciable property, primarily personal property and certain intangible properties. Assets subject to Section 1245 include:

Machinery and Equipment: This includes manufacturing equipment, office machinery, and other similar tangible assets used in business operations.
Vehicles: Business-use vehicles, such as trucks or cars used in the operation of a business, fall under Section 1245.
Furniture and Fixtures: Items such as office furniture, shelves, or other fixed installations are covered by Section 1245.
Certain Intangible Properties: Certain types of intangible assets, like patents, know-how, and intellectual property, that are depreciable or amortizable are also subject to Section 1245 recapture rules.

Essentially, Section 1245 property encompasses personal property that is subject to depreciation or amortization. It excludes real property like buildings and other improvements, which fall under Section 1250.

Calculation of Recapture

Under Section 1245, when an asset is sold, the amount of depreciation or amortization previously deducted is subject to recapture. This amount is taxed as ordinary income up to the total amount of depreciation claimed over the asset’s life.

Recapture the Amount of Depreciation or Amortization Deducted

The basic formula for calculating recapture is straightforward: the portion of the gain from the sale that is attributable to the depreciation deductions is recaptured as ordinary income. Any gain beyond the amount of depreciation is treated as capital gain.

Formula:
- Gain on Sale = Sale Price – Adjusted Basis (original cost minus accumulated depreciation).
- Depreciation Recapture = Lesser of (1) total depreciation deductions taken or (2) gain realized on the sale.

Example: How to Calculate Recapture if an Asset is Sold for More Than Its Adjusted Basis

Imagine a company purchased a piece of machinery for $50,000 and over time took $30,000 in depreciation deductions. The adjusted basis of the machinery is now $20,000 ($50,000 – $30,000). The company sells the machinery for $40,000.

Step 1: Calculate the total gain on the sale:
- $40,000 (sale price) – $20,000 (adjusted basis) = $20,000 gain.
Step 2: Determine the recapture amount:
- The company took $30,000 in depreciation deductions, but the gain is only $20,000. Therefore, the recapture amount is the lesser of the depreciation deductions ($30,000) or the total gain ($20,000).
Step 3: Tax treatment:
- $20,000 of the gain is recaptured as ordinary income under Section 1245.

The remaining $10,000 of depreciation that was deducted is not recaptured because the gain did not exceed the total depreciation taken.

Treatment of Recaptured Gain

The primary tax impact of Section 1245 is that any gain up to the amount of depreciation taken is recaptured as ordinary income. This means the gain is taxed at the taxpayer’s marginal tax rate rather than at the more favorable long-term capital gains rate.

Portion of the Gain Equal to Depreciation is Recaptured as Ordinary Income

As shown in the example, the portion of the gain equal to the amount of depreciation taken ($20,000 in the example) will be taxed as ordinary income. If the sale price had exceeded both the adjusted basis and the amount of depreciation taken, any additional gain beyond the recaptured depreciation would be taxed as capital gain.

Example Calculation for TCP CPA Exam

Let’s assume another example for study purposes:

Purchase Price: $80,000
Depreciation Deductions: $50,000
Adjusted Basis: $80,000 – $50,000 = $30,000
Sale Price: $90,000
Total Gain: $90,000 – $30,000 = $60,000

In this case:

The total depreciation deductions are $50,000.
The gain on sale is $60,000.

Recapture the lesser of the two:

$50,000 (depreciation deductions) vs. $60,000 (total gain), so $50,000 is recaptured as ordinary income.
The remaining $10,000 ($60,000 – $50,000) would be treated as a capital gain.

This is a classic calculation expected on the TCP CPA exam, where candidates must be able to separate ordinary income from capital gain when analyzing Section 1245 recapture.

When Section 1245 Applies: Specific Situations and Real-Life Scenarios

Section 1245 recapture rules apply in various real-life situations where depreciable personal property is sold for a gain. Some typical examples include:

Sale of Business Equipment: A business may sell old machinery or computers that have been fully or partially depreciated. Any gain on the sale of these assets will trigger Section 1245 recapture up to the amount of depreciation.
Disposition of Vehicles Used for Business: If a company sells a business-use vehicle that has been depreciated, the gain from the sale will be recaptured as ordinary income.
Sale of Intangible Assets Like Patents: Patents or similar intangible property used in a business and depreciated over time also fall under Section 1245. Any sale of such assets may result in recapture.
Corporate Asset Sales: When a corporation sells off depreciable assets during a reorganization or liquidation, Section 1245 recapture often applies to the gain on personal property, machinery, or equipment.

Section 1245 depreciation recapture rules are widely applicable to the sale of depreciated personal property, and tax professionals must accurately apply these rules to ensure proper tax treatment of recaptured gain as ordinary income.

Section 1250 Depreciation Recapture

Assets Subject to Section 1250

Section 1250 of the Internal Revenue Code (IRC) applies to the depreciation recapture of real property, which primarily includes buildings and their structural components. These assets are subject to different recapture rules than personal property under Section 1245. Examples of Section 1250 property include:

Buildings: Commercial and residential rental properties, office buildings, warehouses, and factories.
Structural Components: Components such as elevators, heating systems, plumbing, electrical systems, and other permanent fixtures that are part of the building’s structure.

Unlike personal property covered by Section 1245, Section 1250 deals with real property, which typically appreciates in value over time. As a result, depreciation recapture for Section 1250 property focuses on the excess depreciation taken over the straight-line method.

Calculation of Recapture

Section 1250 recapture rules only apply to accelerated depreciation, which exceeds the amount of depreciation that would have been allowed under the straight-line method. If a taxpayer used accelerated depreciation for real property, the excess portion is subject to recapture and taxed as ordinary income. This contrasts with Section 1245, where the entire amount of depreciation is recaptured.

Excess Depreciation Recaptured as Ordinary Income

The recapture amount is determined by calculating the excess depreciation—the amount of depreciation claimed over the amount that would have been allowed using straight-line depreciation. The excess depreciation is taxed as ordinary income.

If straight-line depreciation was used for the entire life of the asset, there is generally no recapture of depreciation under Section 1250, but there may still be unrecaptured gain taxed at a special rate.

Example: How to Calculate Recapture if the Property is Sold

Let’s assume a taxpayer purchased a commercial building for $500,000 and used an accelerated depreciation method that allowed them to depreciate $150,000 over several years. If straight-line depreciation would have been $100,000 over the same period, the excess depreciation is the difference between the two amounts:

Excess Depreciation: $150,000 (accelerated depreciation) – $100,000 (straight-line depreciation) = $50,000.

Now, if the property is sold for $600,000:

Total Gain: $600,000 (sale price) – $350,000 (adjusted basis) = $250,000.
Adjusted basis is $500,000 (purchase price) minus $150,000 (depreciation).
The excess depreciation of $50,000 is recaptured as ordinary income and taxed at the taxpayer’s ordinary income rate.

The remaining gain, after recapturing excess depreciation, is treated differently as described below.

Unrecaptured Section 1250 Gain

Any gain on the sale of a Section 1250 asset that is not recaptured as ordinary income under the excess depreciation rule is classified as unrecaptured Section 1250 gain. This gain is treated as capital gain, but it is subject to a higher tax rate than regular long-term capital gains—up to 25%, rather than the standard 0%, 15%, or 20% rates that apply to most capital gains.

Example Calculation to Illustrate the Concept

Continuing with the previous example:

Total Gain: $250,000
Recaptured Excess Depreciation: $50,000 (taxed as ordinary income)
Unrecaptured Section 1250 Gain: $200,000 (remaining gain)

The unrecaptured Section 1250 gain of $200,000 will be taxed as a capital gain, but at a maximum rate of 25%, instead of the typical long-term capital gains rate. This rate applies because the taxpayer previously benefited from the lower tax rates on depreciation deductions. The 25% tax rate is a compromise between full ordinary income taxation and the more favorable capital gains rates.

When Section 1250 Applies: Specific Situations and Real-Life Scenarios

Section 1250 recapture applies primarily in the sale of depreciable real property where accelerated depreciation methods were used. Some common situations include:

Commercial Real Estate Sales: A business sells a commercial building that has been depreciated using an accelerated method, such as the Modified Accelerated Cost Recovery System (MACRS). The excess depreciation will be recaptured under Section 1250, and the remaining gain will be taxed as unrecaptured Section 1250 gain.
Rental Property Sales: An individual sells a residential rental property where accelerated depreciation was used in earlier years. If the taxpayer used an accelerated method before switching to straight-line depreciation (as required for residential real estate post-1986), the excess depreciation is subject to Section 1250 recapture.
Depreciable Improvements on Real Estate: Depreciable improvements to real estate, such as renovations to buildings, may also trigger Section 1250 recapture if sold at a gain.
Partnerships and Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs): Section 1250 also applies to certain real estate sales made by partnerships and REITs, where depreciation deductions were claimed for real property.

Section 1250 depreciation recapture focuses on the excess depreciation claimed for real property and applies in a wide range of real estate transactions. The rules are more nuanced than those for personal property under Section 1245, and taxpayers must carefully calculate both the recaptured income and the unrecaptured gain to ensure proper tax treatment.

Comparing Section 1245 and 1250 Depreciation Recapture

Summary of the Key Differences Between Section 1245 and Section 1250

Type of Assets Covered

Section 1245: Applies to depreciable personal property such as machinery, equipment, vehicles, and certain intangible assets like patents.
Section 1250: Applies to depreciable real property like buildings and structural components, including commercial and residential real estate.

In essence, Section 1245 governs the recapture of depreciation on personal property, while Section 1250 focuses on real property and its related components.

Calculation Method

Section 1245: Recaptures all depreciation claimed as ordinary income. The amount of recapture is the lesser of (1) the total depreciation taken or (2) the total gain on the sale of the asset.
Section 1250: Recaptures only excess depreciation (accelerated depreciation over what would have been allowed under straight-line depreciation). The excess depreciation is taxed as ordinary income, while the remaining gain is treated as unrecaptured Section 1250 gain, subject to capital gains tax at a rate of up to 25%.

Thus, the primary difference in the calculation method is that Section 1245 recaptures all depreciation, while Section 1250 only recaptures the accelerated portion.

Tax Treatment of the Recaptured Gain

Section 1245: The recaptured gain is taxed as ordinary income, up to the amount of depreciation claimed. Any gain in excess of the depreciation amount is taxed as a capital gain.
Section 1250: The excess depreciation is taxed as ordinary income, but any gain attributable to straight-line depreciation is taxed as unrecaptured Section 1250 gain (up to a maximum of 25%). Any gain above the recaptured and unrecaptured depreciation amounts is taxed at regular capital gains rates (0%, 15%, or 20%).

Overall, both sections tax recaptured depreciation as ordinary income, but Section 1250 also has a separate category of gain taxed at a higher capital gains rate (up to 25%).

Practical Examples Comparing the Two Sections

Example 1: Section 1245 Depreciation Recapture

A business buys a piece of equipment for $100,000 and depreciates it by $70,000 over several years. The adjusted basis is now $30,000. The business then sells the equipment for $90,000.

Gain on Sale: $90,000 (sale price) – $30,000 (adjusted basis) = $60,000 gain.
Recaptured Depreciation (Section 1245): Since the total depreciation taken was $70,000 and the gain is only $60,000, the entire $60,000 is recaptured and taxed as ordinary income.

In this case, under Section 1245, all $60,000 of the gain is taxed as ordinary income, reflecting the depreciation benefit previously received.

Example 2: Section 1250 Depreciation Recapture

A company purchases a commercial building for $500,000 and claims $150,000 in accelerated depreciation. Over time, the building’s adjusted basis is $350,000. The building is sold for $700,000.

Gain on Sale: $700,000 (sale price) – $350,000 (adjusted basis) = $350,000 gain.
Excess Depreciation (Section 1250): Let’s assume straight-line depreciation would have been $100,000, making the excess depreciation $50,000 ($150,000 accelerated depreciation – $100,000 straight-line depreciation). This $50,000 is recaptured as ordinary income.
Unrecaptured Section 1250 Gain: The remaining gain of $300,000 ($350,000 total gain – $50,000 recaptured excess depreciation) is taxed as unrecaptured Section 1250 gain at a maximum rate of 25%.

In this case, under Section 1250, $50,000 is taxed as ordinary income, while the remaining $300,000 is taxed at a higher capital gains rate (up to 25%).

Comparison

In the Section 1245 example, all depreciation is recaptured and taxed as ordinary income, resulting in no capital gains tax treatment for the $60,000 gain.
In the Section 1250 example, only the excess depreciation is recaptured as ordinary income, and the rest of the gain is taxed as capital gains, with part of it subject to the 25% rate for unrecaptured Section 1250 gain.

These examples illustrate how Section 1245 and Section 1250 differ in both the calculation of depreciation recapture and the resulting tax treatment of gains on the sale of depreciable assets.

Impact of Depreciation Recapture on Taxpayers

How Depreciation Recapture Affects an Individual’s or Business’s Taxable Income

Depreciation recapture can have a significant impact on a taxpayer’s taxable income, particularly when selling an asset that has been depreciated over time. The recaptured depreciation amount is taxed as ordinary income, which is typically at a higher rate than capital gains tax. This means that the portion of the gain on the sale of the asset attributable to previous depreciation deductions will increase the taxpayer’s income for the year and potentially push them into a higher tax bracket.

For example, if a business sells a fully depreciated piece of equipment for a gain, the recaptured amount will be added to the business’s taxable income, often resulting in a much larger tax liability than if the gain had been taxed at the lower capital gains rate. Individuals or businesses in high tax brackets may face even steeper tax consequences, as the marginal tax rate can be as high as 37% for individuals.

Thus, depreciation recapture can result in a significantly higher tax bill, making it important for taxpayers to carefully consider how the sale of depreciated assets will affect their total taxable income in a given year.

Potential Planning Strategies to Minimize Tax Liabilities

While depreciation recapture is unavoidable in most cases, taxpayers can employ several strategies to mitigate the impact on their tax liabilities:

Timing of Asset Sales: Taxpayers can plan the timing of the sale to avoid high taxable income years. For instance, selling an asset in a year when overall income is lower may reduce the tax burden caused by recaptured depreciation.
Section 1031 Like-Kind Exchange: Under Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code, taxpayers can defer depreciation recapture if they reinvest the proceeds from the sale of a business or investment property into a similar property. This deferral delays the recapture until the new property is sold, potentially reducing immediate tax consequences.
Capital Loss Offsets: Taxpayers can sell other assets that have declined in value to generate capital losses. These losses can help offset the gain from the sale of the depreciated asset, reducing the overall tax impact.
Installment Sales: If feasible, taxpayers can use an installment sale method to spread the gain (and associated recaptured depreciation) over several years. This allows them to report a portion of the gain each year, potentially keeping them in a lower tax bracket and reducing the annual tax hit.
Charitable Contributions or Deductions: Taxpayers can reduce taxable income in the year of the sale by making charitable contributions or using other deductions. This strategy can help offset the impact of depreciation recapture by lowering overall taxable income.

While these strategies can reduce or defer the tax liabilities from depreciation recapture, it’s important for individuals and businesses to consult with tax professionals to determine the best approach for their specific circumstances.

IRS Reporting Requirements (e.g., Form 4797)

To properly report depreciation recapture, taxpayers are required to complete IRS Form 4797 (Sales of Business Property) when selling depreciated assets used in a trade or business. This form is used to report gains or losses from the sale, exchange, or other disposition of assets, including those subject to recapture under Sections 1245 and 1250.

Part III of Form 4797: This section is specifically for reporting recapture of depreciation under Sections 1245 and 1250. Taxpayers must calculate the recapture amount based on the depreciation deductions taken and report the ordinary income portion on the form.
Part I of Form 4797: Once the recaptured portion has been reported, any remaining gain (such as capital gains on real property not subject to recapture) is reported in Part I. This is important for Section 1250 property, where unrecaptured gain is treated as a capital gain subject to the 25% maximum tax rate.
Schedule D (Capital Gains and Losses): In some cases, capital gains from the sale of depreciated property may also need to be reported on Schedule D if the asset qualifies for capital gains treatment after depreciation recapture.

Failure to properly report depreciation recapture can result in penalties, additional taxes, and complications during an IRS audit. Therefore, completing Form 4797 accurately is essential for ensuring compliance with IRS rules regarding the sale of depreciated assets.

By understanding the impact of depreciation recapture, employing tax planning strategies, and complying with IRS reporting requirements, taxpayers can better manage their tax liabilities when selling depreciated business or investment assets.

Example Problems and Solutions

Section 1245 Depreciation Recapture: Step-by-Step Example

Problem:

A company purchased a piece of machinery for $80,000. Over the course of its useful life, the company depreciated the asset by $60,000, leaving an adjusted basis of $20,000. The company sells the machinery for $70,000.

Question: What is the amount of depreciation recapture under Section 1245, and how should the gain be treated for tax purposes?

Solution:

Step 1: Calculate the total gain on the sale of the asset.

Formula: Gain = Sale Price – Adjusted Basis
Sale Price = $70,000
Adjusted Basis = $80,000 (purchase price) – $60,000 (depreciation) = $20,000
Gain: $70,000 – $20,000 = $50,000

Step 2: Determine the amount of depreciation recapture.

Section 1245 recaptures all depreciation deductions up to the amount of gain. The total depreciation taken is $60,000, but the gain on the sale is only $50,000. The recapture amount is the lesser of the two.

Depreciation recapture = Lesser of (Depreciation Taken, Gain on Sale)
Depreciation Taken = $60,000
Gain on Sale = $50,000

Therefore, the depreciation recapture amount is $50,000.

Step 3: Tax treatment of the gain.

The $50,000 of recaptured depreciation is taxed as ordinary income under Section 1245.
There is no remaining gain to treat as a capital gain, since the entire gain is recaptured as ordinary income.

Conclusion: The entire $50,000 gain from the sale is recaptured and taxed as ordinary income. This is a common scenario on the CPA exam, where candidates need to focus on identifying the correct recapture amount based on the lesser of depreciation taken and the gain.

Section 1250 Depreciation Recapture: Step-by-Step Example

Problem:

A company purchased a commercial building for $500,000 and used accelerated depreciation, resulting in $120,000 of depreciation over the building’s life. If straight-line depreciation would have been $90,000, the excess depreciation is $30,000. The company sells the building for $650,000.

Question: What is the amount of depreciation recapture under Section 1250, and how should the gain be treated for tax purposes?

Solution:

Step 1: Calculate the total gain on the sale of the asset.

Formula: Gain = Sale Price – Adjusted Basis
Sale Price = $650,000
Adjusted Basis = $500,000 (purchase price) – $120,000 (depreciation) = $380,000
Gain: $650,000 – $380,000 = $270,000

Step 2: Determine the amount of excess depreciation subject to recapture.

Section 1250 recaptures only the excess depreciation—the amount of depreciation taken over what would have been allowed under the straight-line method.

Accelerated Depreciation = $120,000
Straight-Line Depreciation = $90,000
Excess Depreciation: $120,000 – $90,000 = $30,000

The $30,000 of excess depreciation is recaptured as ordinary income.

Step 3: Determine the amount of unrecaptured Section 1250 gain.

After recapturing the excess depreciation, the remaining gain is treated as unrecaptured Section 1250 gain, which is taxed at a maximum rate of 25%.

Total Gain: $270,000
Excess Depreciation Recapture: $30,000 (ordinary income)
Unrecaptured Section 1250 Gain: $270,000 – $30,000 = $240,000

The $240,000 is taxed as a capital gain, but it may be subject to the special 25% rate for unrecaptured Section 1250 gain.

Conclusion:

$30,000 of the gain is taxed as ordinary income under Section 1250, representing the recapture of excess depreciation.
The remaining $240,000 is taxed as unrecaptured Section 1250 gain, subject to a maximum 25% capital gains tax rate.

This example demonstrates the key differences between Sections 1245 and 1250 recapture, emphasizing that under Section 1250, only the excess depreciation is recaptured, while the remaining gain is treated more favorably for tax purposes.

Thought Process for Applying These Tax Rules on the CPA Exam

When approaching questions on the CPA exam regarding depreciation recapture, the key steps involve:

Identify the Type of Asset: Determine if the asset is personal property (Section 1245) or real property (Section 1250), as the recapture rules differ.
Calculate the Gain: Always start by calculating the total gain on the sale of the asset, which is the sale price minus the adjusted basis (original cost minus depreciation).
Determine the Recapture Amount: For Section 1245 assets, the entire amount of depreciation is recaptured up to the gain. For Section 1250 assets, only the excess depreciation is recaptured as ordinary income.
Apply the Appropriate Tax Treatment: Once the recapture amount is determined, recognize that it is taxed as ordinary income. For Section 1250 property, calculate any unrecaptured gain subject to the special 25% capital gains rate.

By following these steps, candidates can systematically approach depreciation recapture problems, ensuring that they properly calculate the recapture amount and apply the correct tax treatment. The CPA exam frequently tests candidates’ ability to differentiate between the recapture rules of Sections 1245 and 1250, so practicing these steps is crucial.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Misunderstanding the Type of Property Subject to Section 1245 vs. Section 1250

One of the most common errors taxpayers and CPA exam candidates make is misclassifying the type of property subject to Section 1245 versus Section 1250. Understanding the difference between personal property and real property is crucial for applying the correct recapture rules.

Section 1245 applies to personal property such as machinery, equipment, vehicles, and certain intangible assets like patents. Depreciation on these assets is fully recaptured as ordinary income.
Section 1250 applies to real property, including buildings and structural components. Here, only excess depreciation over straight-line depreciation is recaptured as ordinary income, while the remaining gain is treated as unrecaptured Section 1250 gain, subject to a special capital gains rate.

Pitfall: Mistaking real property for personal property (or vice versa) can lead to incorrectly calculating the recaptured depreciation. For example, treating a commercial building as Section 1245 property and recapturing all depreciation as ordinary income instead of just the excess depreciation is a common mistake.

Miscalculating the Recaptured Amount and Incorrect Tax Treatment

Another frequent error involves miscalculating the recapture amount. For Section 1245 property, all depreciation is subject to recapture as ordinary income, but for Section 1250 property, only the excess depreciation is recaptured. Misunderstanding this distinction can lead to:

Over-reporting income for Section 1250 property, by including all depreciation as recaptured income instead of only the excess amount.
Under-reporting income for Section 1245 property, by failing to recapture the full amount of depreciation as ordinary income.

Additionally, failing to apply the special 25% capital gains rate for unrecaptured Section 1250 gain is a key mistake. Unrecaptured Section 1250 gain is not treated like standard capital gains, and applying the incorrect tax rate can result in misfiling and tax penalties.

Pitfall: A common mistake is applying the wrong tax treatment to the gain—treating all gains as capital gains without recognizing that part of the gain is taxed at ordinary income rates due to depreciation recapture.

Key Mistakes Made on the CPA Exam Regarding These Topics

On the CPA exam, candidates often make the following errors:

Confusing Sections 1245 and 1250: Candidates sometimes fail to differentiate between personal property and real property, leading to incorrect application of the recapture rules.
Failing to Calculate Excess Depreciation for Section 1250 Property: For Section 1250 property, candidates may overlook the concept of excess depreciation and mistakenly attempt to recapture all depreciation as ordinary income, rather than just the excess over straight-line depreciation.
Neglecting Unrecaptured Section 1250 Gain Rules: Many candidates fail to apply the 25% capital gains rate for unrecaptured Section 1250 gain. This special rate is frequently tested on the CPA exam, and failure to understand it can lead to incorrect answers.
Incorrectly Calculating Gains for Partially Depreciated Assets: Candidates may also miscalculate gains when assets are only partially depreciated. This leads to incorrect identification of the recapture amount and misapplication of capital gains tax treatment for the remaining gain.

Pitfall: Not reading exam questions carefully to determine whether the asset is personal or real property, and whether accelerated or straight-line depreciation was used, often leads to incorrect responses on depreciation recapture questions.

How to Avoid These Pitfalls

Clarify the Asset Type: Always start by identifying whether the asset is personal property (Section 1245) or real property (Section 1250) to apply the correct depreciation recapture rules.
Verify the Depreciation Method: Ensure you are aware of the depreciation method used for the asset—particularly for real property, where only excess depreciation is recaptured under Section 1250.
Double-Check Calculations: Pay close attention to the gain calculation, adjusted basis, and the lesser of depreciation taken or gain realized. For Section 1250, don’t forget to factor in the unrecaptured gain taxed at the special 25% rate.

By understanding these common pitfalls and how to avoid them, both taxpayers and CPA exam candidates can ensure they apply depreciation recapture rules accurately and avoid costly mistakes.

Conclusion

Recap the Importance of Understanding Depreciation Recapture Under Sections 1245 and 1250

Depreciation recapture is a critical concept for both tax professionals and CPA candidates, as it affects how gains on the sale of depreciated assets are treated for tax purposes. Section 1245 governs the recapture of depreciation on personal property, where all depreciation is recaptured as ordinary income. On the other hand, Section 1250 applies to real property, with recapture limited to the excess depreciation over straight-line methods, and any unrecaptured gain being taxed at a special 25% capital gains rate.

Understanding the differences between these two sections is essential for accurately calculating tax liabilities and avoiding potential errors. Misclassifying assets or miscalculating recapture can result in significant tax consequences, so it is vital to apply the correct rules based on the type of property and the depreciation method used.

Encourage CPA Candidates to Focus on the Differences in Tax Treatments and Practice Calculations

For CPA exam candidates, mastering depreciation recapture under Sections 1245 and 1250 is not just about memorizing rules—it’s about applying them in real-life scenarios and exam problems. The exam often tests candidates’ ability to distinguish between personal and real property, accurately calculate gains, and apply the correct tax treatments for depreciation recapture. Therefore, it is crucial for candidates to focus on:

Recognizing asset types to apply the appropriate section.
Practicing detailed calculations for both sections to ensure they understand the correct tax treatment for recaptured depreciation.
Grasping the impact of unrecaptured Section 1250 gain and the special 25% rate.

By regularly practicing example problems and staying sharp on the distinctions between Sections 1245 and 1250, candidates can confidently tackle these topics on the CPA exam and in professional tax practice.